Understanding Farmers | A Mindful Sceptic Guide

When food prices rise, everyone blames farmers for profiteering.

When environmental problems emerge, activists point fingers at agricultural practices. When supermarket shelves are empty, consumers demand explanations from producers.

But what if the entire narrative about modern farming, from "greedy agribusiness" to "environmental destroyers", misses the actual complexity of feeding 8 billion people?

What if farmers aren't the villains in our food story, but the problem-solvers we consistently misunderstand?

In urban circles, farmers are often painted as villains or victims. They’re accused of damaging the land, resisting progress, or dragging their boots through policy reform.

But what if that view is too narrow or just plain wrong?

About the Book

Understanding Farmers asks a deceptively simple question: What if farmers aren't anti-environment, but differently environmental? Drawing on years of work across Australian landscapes, John Mark Dangerfield and Christopher M Scott explore the lived experience of farming communities — not through romanticism or disdain, but through understanding.

This is a guide to a mindset, a moral framework, and a practical philosophy forged in dust, drought, and deeply felt responsibility. It challenges policy wonks, activists, and city-dwellers alike to reconsider the story they’ve been told about farming and to reckon with a deeper, more respectful picture of agricultural wisdom. It’s not about defending everything farmers do. It’s about asking why they do it — and what we might learn if we stopped talking past them.

Why Read This Book?

You’ll understand how farmers see the land, and why that matters for policy and reform
You’ll see how environmentalism looks different when your livelihood depends on it
You’ll gain language to engage with rural perspectives without condescension
You’ll sharpen your ability to navigate rural-urban divides with empathy and rigour

Who It’s For

This guide is for:

Policy professionals, environmental thinkers, and urban sceptics
Rural readers looking for a fair reckoning with their world
Anyone tired of simplistic narratives about farming and the environment

It’s not for:

Readers expecting rural caricatures or easy villains
Those unwilling to sit with moral complexity and lived contradictions

A Taste from Inside

“Farmers are not anti-environment. They’re just working from a different environmental script.”
“The idea that farmers are reluctant to change is often a projection from people who have never had to change their own practices at the edge of viability.”
“Policy tends to imagine landholders as either greedy or ignorant. Both frames are lazy.”
“City narratives about the bush are often long on moral clarity and short on actual knowledge.”
“The reformer’s blind spot is mistaking disagreement for ignorance. Many farmers understand the arguments; they just don’t agree with the premises.”

About the Authors

Dr John Mark Dangerfield and Christopher M Scott are environmental systems thinkers with dirt under their nails and nuance in their notebooks. They’ve spent years working with farmers, including Chris, and this book is their attempt to bridge the gap between evidence, empathy, and action.

"I've advised governments on environmental matters and worked directly with farmers facing impossible trade-offs between economic survival and environmental stewardship. The public discourse about agriculture consistently misses these nuances." Mark Dangerfield

Take the Next Step

Buy the book…

Buy on Amazon

Not Yet Ready to Buy?

Subscribe for free to the Mindful Sceptic newsletter for weekly essays that think as hard as you do.